Your Cart
Your Shipping is Free!
Free Shipping only $50.00 Away
WAS: $0.00 SUBTOTAL: $0.00 You are saving: $0.00

Other Products You May Love

30 DAY SATISFACTION GUARANTEED
OVER 100,000 MEN HAVE SHOPPED PRIVATELY WITH US

THE ENHANCEDMALE REWARDS

Join for Free and enjoy free store credit with every order, Free Product Giveaways, Exclusive Discounts
Early access to limited edition products, Zero commitment, cancel anytime

JOIN THE REWARDS PROGRAM
CheckoutSecure CheckoutDiscreet Checkout

Butt plugs are among the most popular sex toys around. Take a look at any good sex toy retailer and you'll be met with a huge array of plugs in order to meet such intense demand! What's the reason for their immense popularity? It's simple really: butt plugs are brilliant!

Not only are they super reliable, being a tried and tested way of achieving anal pleasure and prostate orgasms, but they come in so many different varieties - so many in fact that choosing which plug is the best for your specific needs can be quite the conundrum!

Regardless of whether you're a beginner who's looking to obtain their very first plug or a seasoned butt plug pro hoping to add something truly outstanding to their collection, we're here for you. We've put together this handy list containing the plugs that we consider to be the best choices for men looking to expand their arsenal in 2023!

After taking a look at each plug, we'll go over some of the things you need to think about to narrow down your choice, including material, features, and size. What are you waiting for - let's find you your perfect plug!

Best Butt Plugs of 2023: Our Recommendations

Overall Best Butt Plug

B-Vibe Rimming Plug 2 | Rotating and Vibrating Butt Plug for Men

Best Butt Plug for Beginners

Mighty 3.5" Mini Rechargeable 20 Speed Silicone Anal Plug

Best Premium Butt Plug

B-Vibe Vibrating & Weighted Snug Plug Black XL

Best Vibrating Butt Plug

Backdoor Banger Thumping Silicone Rechargeable Anal Vibrator with Remote Control

Best Rubber Butt Plug

Titanmen Master Tool No.4 Triple Bump Butt Plug

Best Glass Butt Plug

Icicles No. 47 Clear Glass Anal Plug by Pipedream Products

Best Silicone Butt Plug

Mood Naughty Black Silicone Butt Plug by Doc Johnson

Best Rotating Butt Plug

Anal Adventures Platinum 5.75 Inch Drive Rechargeable Silicone Butt Plug by Blush Novelties

Best Hollow Tunnel Butt Plug

Anal Fantasy Elite Small Anal Gaper Clear Glass Open-Tunnel Butt Plug by Pipedream

Best Butt Plug Kit

Colt Silicone Anal Trainer Butt Plug Kit by Cal Exotics

B-Vibe Rimming Plug 2 | Rotating and Vibrating Butt Plug for Men
B-Vibe Rimming Plug 2 | Rotating and Vibrating Butt Plug for Men

Price: $$$ Material: Medical-grade silicone
Best for: Men seeking advanced features and ease of use Functions: Vibrating, Rotating
Insertable length: 4.8 Inches Width: 1.5 Inches
Safety features: Phthalate-Free, Non-Toxic, Latex-Free, Splash-Proof Features: Easy to use and clean, USB rechargeable, Includes wireless remote control, Flared base, 7 unique modes and settings

What does it take to be crowned the overall best butt plug available on our site? Only the original dual-motor butt plug, which both rotates and vibrates to replicate the feeling of a world-class rimjob!

There are 7 unique modes to play with here, each of which features different speeds and intensities of the vibrations and rotations.

Cycling through these modes is super easy with the included wireless remote control, making finding your perfect settings an absolute joy.

The body of the plug is built from premium, seamless medical-grade silicone which is incredibly comfortable, and thanks to the flared base, it stays perfectly in place. All the orgasmic vibrations are courtesy of a discreet motor in the tip of the plug that, though quiet, is a real beast!

Found in the stem of the plug are several rows of spinning beads - these provide the rotating sensation which really makes all the difference when it comes to achieving immense orgasms! At the bottom of the plug you'll find the flared base which helps keep the plug nice and safe, and works well as a stand.

With the included USB charger, it's simple to keep the plug charged and ready to go. It even comes with a discreet carrying case, and an anal play guide. It's simple really - the Rimming Plug 2 is easy to use, powerfully pleasurable, and features just the right number of modes to ensure there's something for everyone. That's why it won multiple awards, and why it's the overall best!

Pros and Cons

Pros
First ever rotating butt plug
Powerful motor and rotating beads stimulate your prostate and your rim
Even better than a real rimjob thanks to additional prostate stimulation
7 intense modes for speed and vibrations
Easy to control with included wireless remote
Premium body-safe silicone design
Rechargeable with the included cable
Splash-proof (just don't submerge)
Easy to clean
Cons
Only compatible with water-based lube
Some users found vibrations to be more powerful than the rotations
Some users who had never used anal toys had to work their way up to using the plug
Check Price Now

Mighty 3.5" Mini Rechargeable 20 Speed Silicone Anal Plug
Mighty 3.5" Mini Rechargeable 20 Speed Silicone Anal Plug

Price: $$ Material: Premium silicone
Best for:  Men seeking smaller vibrating butt plugs on a budget, Adventure seekers wanting wild stimulation Functions: Vibrating, Weighted
Insertable length:  3.25 Inches Width: 1 Inch
Safety features: Flared base, Hypoallergenic, Nonporous, Phthalate-Free, Waterproof and submersible   Features: Wireless remote, Feels superior, Luxurious, and Ultra-Velvety, USB rechargeable, Easy to control, Features 20 unique speeds 

Even though the anal play is a lot less taboo than it used to be, it can still (understandably!) be a little daunting for beginners. If you're just starting out, you need a plug that makes insertion as easy as possible to guarantee you have a pleasurable experience - the Mighty Mini from Evolved Novelties may well be that plug!

With its soft medical-grade silicone body and its 20 unique settings, it's clear that Evolved Novelties didn't sacrifice features for beginner-friendliness.

That comes from its size - it's 3.5 inches tall and 1 inch wide, making it perfect for anyone who's just getting into butt plugs! The bulbous shape and tapered tip of this plug also help make for comfortable, easy insertion. Once inside, it's easy to thrust and won't get stuck thanks to the flared base, meaning it's also super safe. Located on the base is the button which is used to cycle through those 20 speed and function settings, letting you work up from teasing to powerful stimulation!

Featuring a fully waterproof design, you can even take the Mighty Mini with you in the shower. On a full charge, you should be able to get up to 1 hour of fun, and charging is easy with the included cable. Great for beginners and those with more experience, this butt plug may be undersized, but it's not to be underestimated!

Pros and Cons

Pros
First ever rotating butt plug
Powerful motor and rotating beads stimulate your prostate and your rim
Even better than a real rimjob thanks to additional prostate stimulation
7 intense modes for speed and vibrations
Easy to control with included wireless remote
Premium body-safe silicone design
Rechargeable with the included cable
Splash-proof (just don't submerge)
Easy to clean
Cons
Only compatible with water-based lube
Some users found vibrations to be more powerful than the rotations
Some users who had never used anal toys had to work their way up to using the plug
Check Price Now

B-Vibe Vibrating & Weighted Snug Plug Black XL
B-Vibe Vibrating & Weighted Snug Plug Black XL

Price: $$$ Material: Medical-grade silicone
Best for: Experienced users looking for something premium to upgrade to Functions: Vibrating, Weighted
Insertable length: 5.35 Inches Width: 1.7 Inches
Safety features: Phthalate-Free, Latex-Free, Nonporous Features:  Easy to use, Flexible neck and a smooth grip handle, USB Rechargeable, Travel-Friendly

For experienced users of butt plugs, there comes a time when you'll want to upgrade to fancier, more decadent toys which allow for even greater sensations. The B-Vibe vibrating snug plug is a premium weighted plug perfect for anyone ready to really invest in their pleasure!

Due to its sumptuous materials and weighted nature, this medical-grade silicone butt plug feels amazing even before utilizing any of the features. Its torpedo-style shape also allows for easy insertion, meaning you won't have any difficulty at all getting it nice and comfortable inside you.

Once you're done marveling at the sensual feeling of fullness and pressure, the real fun can begin, with the plug's 4 intense vibration settings and 6 unique patterns.

Each speed and pattern is valuable as you work your way up to an earth-shattering prostate orgasm!

The best way to use this plug - and most plugs for that matter - is with a ton of water-based lube for a pleasurably slick experience. Once fully charged with the included USB cable, you're ready for a night of astonishing anal play. With the flexible neck which ends in a handle, the plug remains safe through extensive use.

The price tag may be premium, but this plug makes up for that in spades with the supreme comfort that comes from the combination of its shape, XL size, weight, seamless silicone design, and included travel bag. Combine all that with the various settings of vibrations, and it's easy to see why the B-Vibe Vibrating & Weighted snug plug is really a winner!

Pros and Cons

Pros
Premium XL vibrating and weighted plug
Perfect for butt-plug veterans
The plug weighs 247 grams for a super satisfying feeling of fullness
The torpedo shape makes insertion incredibly comfortable
Vibration with 4 intensities and 6 patterns meaning there's a power level for everyone
Super soft premium silicone design which is seamless for comfort
A flexible neck with a handle adds comfort and safety
Includes a booklet full of anal tips from sex educators
Includes travel bag so you can take your plug anywhere
The battery recharges with the included cable
Cons
Only compatible with water-based lube
Might be too big for anyone without experience
Some users wished the buttons were easier to access
Check Price Now

Backdoor Banger Thumping Silicone Rechargeable Anal Vibrator with Remote Control
Backdoor Banger Thumping Silicone Rechargeable Anal Vibrator with Remote Control

Price: $$ Material: Medical-grade silicone
Best for: Men who enjoy vibrations and thrusting action Functions: Vibrating, Thrusting, Weighted 
Insertable length: 4 Inches Width: 1.55 Inches
Safety features: Hypoallergenic, Nonporous, Phthalate-Free, Waterproof Features: Wireless remote, USB Rechargeable, 7 pulsating functions, Wide base for easy grip, Graduating bump shaft adds additional stretch

Vibrations are one of the best ways to achieve a truly mind-blowing prostate orgasm. With help from the Backdoor Banger, your orgasms are about to get a lot more frequent and a lot more intense - there's nothing quite like it!

Really though, the vibrations aren't even half of it. This plug gets its name from its magnetic thumping capabilities, which drive you closer and closer to climax as it pulses and thrusts right where you want it the most.

Using the included remote control, you have free reign over which of the 7 settings to use - these settings range all the way from delicate teasing to powerful pumping!

You can even hand the control over to a partner to take your intimate encounters to the next level. Solo or with a partner this butt plug is an awesome asset, and since it's waterproof, you can even use it in the bath.

The shaft of the plug features bumps which gradually increase inside, adding to the ecstasy as you insert and remove the plug, and also making the thrusting that much more pleasurable. Safety should always be a concern when it comes to butt play, and this plug has you covered with its medical-grade silicone and flared base, which also makes the plug very comfortable.

With the included charger, it's easy to get it right up to full power, and you'll get one hour's usage from an hour and a half of charging - meaning you should get a good few uses out of it before you need to recharge. The Backdoor Banger is one hell of a vibrating butt plug, and is the best way to intensify your anal play!

Pros and Cons

Pros
Vibrating and thrusting butt plug helps you achieve stupendous orgasms
7 unique rhythms for a varied experience from teasing to thumping
Graduating bumps on the shaft increase pressure and add to the pleasure
Soft medical-grade silicone is safe and comfortable
Controlling settings is easy with included remote
Great for sex with or without a partner
The base is wide for safety and grip
Includes USB cable for charging
Fully waterproof
Cons
Only compatible with water-based lube
Some users wished the thrusts went even deeper but mentioned they were happy with the product
Might not be the best for beginners
Check Price Now

Titanmen Master Tool No.4 Triple Bump Butt Plug
Titanmen Master Tool No.4 Triple Bump Butt Plug

Price: $$ Material: PVC rubber
Best for: Men looking for a serious stretch, More advanced users, Perfect for use alone or as a couple Functions: Classic butt plug
Insertable length: 6 Inches Width: 2.5 Inches
Safety features: Flared base, Phthalate-Free, Non-Toxic, Body-Safe, Waterproof Features: Uniquely shaped triple bubble design,  XL size, Extremely comfortable for extended wear, Flared base

The Titanmen Master Tool No.4 is not for the faint of heart! Its XL size and triple bump design are intended to stretch your butt to its absolute limits in the most pleasurable way possible - if you're up for the challenge, we think it'll blow you away!

Just by looking at it, you can tell this is a butt plug meant only for those with experience and a desire to really push themselves in search of pleasure they never knew was possible

The design is quite simple, featuring three bubbles that range from large to enormous! Insertion is definitely going to be a challenge - the first bubble is already 6 inches in circumference! The bubbles only get bigger from here, with the medium one being 6.75 inches and the largest clocking in at an eye-watering 8.25 inches! This is a truly intense plug, but its sleek black PVC body ensures that once you've gathered the strength to fully take it on, you're rewarded with a feeling of pressure and fullness that is totally unrivaled.

The plug is also very simple to clean as it has no fancy components, and is entirely waterproof. Speaking of water, water-based lube is CRUCIAL for use with this plug - you'll need it to be as slick as possible to stand a chance! The Titanmen Master Tool No.4 is a formidable opponent, but with the right amount of courage, patience, and lube, it can and will be conquered!

Pros and Cons

Pros
Huge butt plug which will satisfy even the most experienced users
Features 3 bubbles that get gradually bigger for an intensely pleasurable challenge
Size alone guarantees stimulation of your entire butt
The sleek black PVC plug is nice and comfortable
The flared base is great for safety and grip
Fully waterproof
100% Body-safe
Users report a sense of accomplishment after finally taking the whole plug!
Cons
Definitely too big for beginners - but that's obvious!
Only compatible with water-based lube
Check Price Now

Customer Reviews

 

"New horizons. Never experienced this massive toy before. It's a thrilling accomplishment."

MMichael B.

Icicles No. 47 Clear Glass Anal Plug by Pipedream Products
Icicles No. 47 Clear Glass Anal Plug by Pipedream Products

Price$$ Material: Pyrex glass
Best for: Men looking for something different from a silicone plug, or who want to use silicone lube Functions: Temperature-receptive as it can be warmed up or chilled cold
Insertable length: 3.5 Inches Width: 1.4 Inches
Safety features: , Hypoallergenic, Nonporous, Body-safe, Waterproof, Dishwasher safe Features: Three graduated glass beads, Can be used for temperature play, Ergonomic and wide base, Easy to clean

Not every butt plug looks as good as this. With its crystal clear, hand-blown pyrex glass build, Icicles No. 47 by Pipedream is as much a fantastic anal toy as it is an elegant piece of modern art!

Thankfully, the function has not been sacrificed for form with Icicles No. 47. In classic butt plug fashion, this classy toy features graduated spheres that are perfectly smooth and sleek, making insertion feel super luxurious.

Since it's glass, this plug is especially firm, allowing your anal muscles to wrap around and squeeze it without squashing, and making every thrust a dream.

The neck of the plug is fairly long and features a wide base which both makes the toy safe and helps you get a good grip for thrusting and removal. Though it doesn't have a tapered tip, the initial glass sphere is quite small, meaning you shouldn't have a problem with insertion.

Let's talk about glass sex toys for a moment. Sex toys made from glass are exquisitely slick and smooth, and they have a great weight to them which makes them super satisfying to use. They are naturally body-safe, very durable, and have the added bonus of being easily heated or cooled however you like. They can even be used with silicone-based lube for extra slickness and cushioning!

Essentially, glass sex toys are a classy and unique alternative to the usual silicone and rubber. If you don't have one already, we'd recommend adding one to your collection - and Icicles No.47 is ready and waiting for you!

Pros and Cons

Pros
Sleek and firm glass butt plug for all kinds of anal play
Hand-blown glass toy is very classy and durable
Features graduated glass beads for an increasingly pleasurable experience
Super smooth and excellent weight for ultimate satisfaction
Can be heated or cooled how you like
Very easy to clean
Can be used with water-based and silicone-based lube
Cons
Users might need to take some time to get used to the sensation of glass
Maybe a little small for experienced users
Can feel cold at first, but will soon warm-up
Check Price Now

Mood Naughty Black Silicone Butt Plug by Doc Johnson
Mood Naughty Black Silicone Butt Plug by Doc Johnson

Price$$ Material: Medical-grade silicone
Best for: Beginners looking for a great plug to start wish, Ideal for solo play or with a partner Functions: Classic smooth anal plug
Insertable lengths: 4 Sizes available: Small (3 Inches), Medium (3.75 Inches), Large (4.75 Inches), Extra-Large (5.5 Inches)
Width: 4 Sizes available: Small (1 Inche), Medium (1 Inch), Large (1.25 Inches), Extra-Large (1.5 Inches)
Safety features: Phthalate-Free, Hypoallergenic, Waterproof Features: Tapered design allows for easy and comfortable penetration, Available in small to extra large sizes, Curved base for easy grip

The classics are always worth returning to every now and then, especially if you're used to fancy toys with complex features. When it comes to simplicity and ease of use, it doesn't get much better than the Mood Naughty black silicone butt plugs from Doc Johnson. They even come in 4 sizes, meaning beginners and more experienced users can get whichever suits them the best!

These are what you imagine when you think of butt plugs - sumptuously soft silicone with a tapered tip, the perfect texture and shape for easy insertion, and great for wearing throughout the day thanks to the curved base.

When it comes to simplicity and ease of use, it doesn't get much better than the Mood Naughty black silicone butt plugs from Doc Johnson.

No matter which size you choose small, medium, large, or extra large, these plugs are super comfortable, and provide just the right amount of pressure and prostate stimulation to be a thrill every time!

Mood Naughty black plugs are also nice and safe to use due to the base acting as a curved handle - it's easy to remove the plug whenever you like. The medical-grade silicone build is fully waterproof and an absolute breeze to clean.

These plugs may be simple, but no self-respecting man's butt plug collection is complete without one - they're an enduring classic for a reason!

Pros and Cons

Pros
Soft silicone plugs with sizes for beginners and veterans
You can work up from small all the way to extra large
Just the right amount of stretch and pressure
Tapered tip for easy insertion and prostate stimulation
The curved base acts as a handle for safety
Comfortable enough to wear all-day
Premium silicone build
Fully waterproof and easy to clean
Cons
Only compatible with water-based lube
Anything other than extra large might not be enough for more experienced users
Check Price Now

Anal Adventures Platinum 5.75 Inch Drive Rechargeable Silicone Butt Plug by Blush Novelties
Anal Adventures Platinum 5.75 Inch Drive Rechargeable Silicone Butt Plug by Blush Novelties

Price$$ Material: Pure platinum cured Puria silicone
Best for: Men who love rimjob sensations, Both beginner or advanced anal adventurers Functions: Vibrating, Gyrating, Rotating
Insertable length:  4 Inches Width: 1.5 Inches
Safety features: , Phthalate-Free, Non-Toxic, Waterproof, Easy to clean, Small and discreet Features:  Wide anchor base, 10 Vibrating functions, Wireless remote control, Compact design, Rechargeable 

Here's another vibrating and rotating butt plug, but this time the rotations are absolutely the star of the show. The Anal Adventures Platinum features multiple rows of pleasure beads that rotate in just the right way to drive you wild!

The 10 vibrating functions along with the rotating beads are controlled with the included wireless remote for hands-free enjoyment, which is also facilitated by the unique anchor base. It's also super easy to insert the plug thanks to its smooth, penis head tip.

Built out of platinum-cured Puria silicone, this plug is soft as can be and gently warms to your body temperature for an extremely comfortable experience.

It's also waterproof, meaning you aren't just limited to using it in the bedroom - it can make any ordinary bath or shower a memorable experience!

The easy-to-insert penis tip and wide range of vibration and rotation settings mean that this butt plug is a great buy for anyone regardless of their level of experience - both beginners and veterans will be able to get something good out of this one.

The Anal Adventures Platinum butt plug is packed with features, super simple to use thanks to the remote control, and also dirt-proof which makes remaining hygienic a piece of cake. Are you ready to ramp up your sex life with a rotating toy? If so, this plug is for you!

Pros and Cons

Pros
Vibrating plug with rotating beads for rim stimulation
10 intense vibration settings
Easy insertion thanks to penis head tip
Great for beginners and veterans alike
Built from amazingly smooth and body-safe platinum-cured Puria silicone
Fully waterproof
Rechargeable battery
Dirt-proof and very easy to keep clean
Cons
Only compatible with water-based lube
Penis-style design isn't for everyone
Check Price Now

Anal Fantasy Elite Small Anal Gaper Clear Glass Open-Tunnel Butt Plug by Pipedream
Anal Fantasy Elite Small Anal Gaper Clear Glass Open-Tunnel Butt Plug by Pipedream

Price$$ Material: Borosilicate glass
Best for: Men who are interested or experienced with gapers, or who are looking for ways to increase stimulation, Solo play or with a partner Functions: Liquid play and enemas, Anal gaper
Insertable length: 3 Inches Width: 1.4 Inches
Safety features: Hypoallergenic, Waterproof, Easy to clean, Small and discreet, Phthalate-Free, Latex-Free Features: Hollow tunnel for inserting additional toys, Crystal clear build for a great view, Tapered tip for easy access 

Anal gapers are unique toys that focus on stimulating your ass through stretching - hence the name! To safely experience all the joys of gapers, you need an excellent toy that is perfectly smooth to guarantee a perfect gape. Luckily, Pipedream has done it again with the Anal Fantasy Elite, which is the perfect gaper for both first-timers and gaping pros!

This is a crystal clear glass plug that is exquisitely smooth and slick - especially with lube - and also gives users an awesome view as you gape into ecstasy.

Built into the toy is a hollow tunnel, which is just the right shape to allow for the insertion of other anal toys and body-safe objects and liquids. You could even use your (or a partner's) finger for even more delectable prostate stimulation!

Thanks to the premium borosilicate glass material, this plug is compatible with water and silicone lube, the latter of which pairs perfectly with the toy, providing a whole new level of slickness and cushioning. This, along with the tapered tip, makes the toy very easy to use, even if you're new to gapers.

This plug is nice and easy to clean with soapy water, and due to the flared base, you don't need to be worried about it getting sucked too far in. As we mentioned earlier, if you're looking to get into gapers, you need to ensure you get the best toy for the job - you can't go wrong with Pipedream's Anal Fantasy Elite!

Pros and Cons

Pros
Unique hollow tunnel anal gaper plug
Gives the perfect stretch
Crystal clear borosilicate glass build is super slick and firm
A hollow tunnel allows extra toys and body-safe objects and liquids to be inserted for even more pleasure
Clear material gives a great view of the action
Tapered tip and smooth glass makes insertion easy, even for beginners
Very easy to clean
Compatible with water-based and silicone-based lube
Cons
Might not be large enough for super-experienced users
Can be cold at first but soon warms up to body temperature
Check Price Now

Colt Silicone Anal Trainer Butt Plug Kit by Cal Exotics
Colt Silicone Anal Trainer Butt Plug Kit by Cal Exotics

Price$$ Material: Premium silicone
Best for: Both beginners and experienced anal players. Functions: Classic anal trainer
Insertable length: Comes in 3 Sizes: Small (4 Inches), Medium (4.25 Inches) and Large (5 Inches) Width: Comes in 3 Sizes: Small (1 Inch), Medium (1.25 Inches) and Large (1.5 Inches)
Safety features:  Small size for beginners, Phthalate-Free, Waterproof and submersible Features: 3 tapered plugs graduated in size, Suction cup base for hands-free stimulation, Ergonomic stopper

With their silicone anal trainer butt plug kit, Cal Exotics has made getting into butt plugs (and anal sex) both convenient and pleasurable! Whether you're a beginner, or have experience and are looking to expand your horizons even further, this kit is all you need to safely work up to larger toys - and body parts!

Anal training kits are fairly straightforward - you start with the smallest toy, and once you're used to that one, you move on to the next size up, and so on. There are three plugs in this kit which are graduated from a width of 1 inch to 1.25 inches, and finally 1.5 inches.

Using kits such as this really is the best way to comfortably get used to anal toys.

Even though you get three plugs here, the manufacturers didn't skimp out on the quality - each of these plugs is made from premium body-safe silicone which is soft as velvet. The tips are also tapered, which is especially useful if you're using them for the intended training purpose! Each plug also has a flared base to keep them safe.

Training isn't the only thing these plugs are great for though, as using them is as sensationally pleasurable as you'd hope, with the capability to provide intense prostate orgasms! Anal training is always a great idea, and with their Colt silicone anal training kit, Cal Exotics has made it as pleasurable as possible!

Pros and Cons

Pros
Anal training kit lets you gradually get used to bigger and bigger plugs
Great for beginners and experienced users alike
Tapered tip for easy insertion
Flared base for safety and grip
The base is also a suction cup for hands-free fun
Contains three soft silicone plugs
Perfect for training and stimulating your prostate
Silicone is body safe and easy to clean
Fully waterproof
Cons
Only compatible with water-based lube
Probably won't be big enough for butt-plug veterans
Check Price Now

How to choose a butt plug

So - those are the butt plugs that we believe to be the best on our site, with each one being a standout in its individual category. I'm sure a few have caught your eye, but that only complicates things if you're looking to find your perfect plug!

To that end, here we'll go over a few of the things you need to keep in mind in order to narrow down your choice out of all these incredible plugs, to land on one that you can be confident will be the best for your needs!


How to Choose  a Butt Plug Diagram

Know the materials

All the plugs on this list are made from one of two materials: silicone or glass. Whichever of these materials a plug is built from can greatly affect a number of things, such as how it feels, how it reacts to temperature, and what kinds of lube it can be safely used with!

Most of the plugs we've listed are silicone plugs, and that's not just any silicone; premium medical-grade silicone is the only choice for anything silicone that will be inserted inside your body!

Silicone toys are often super soft and velvety, feeling incredible to touch and insert. These toys will usually remain at a fairly consistent temperature.

However, most silicone toys are only compatible with water-based lube - it's important to always check the labels and instructions of any toy or lube you purchase to find out any compatibility issues.

Glass toys on the other hand are exquisitely very firm, which makes them easy to insert (especially with lube) and gives a much different feeling as your muscles squeeze around the plug. Glass plugs can be quite cold, but are easily heated and will warm up to body temperature as you use them. If you're into the slipperiness and cushioning of silicone lube, you're in luck here as most glass toys can be used with it - but once again, always check labels and instructions for compatibility.

Consider vibrating features

There's no better way to guarantee an explosive ending than by using a butt plug that can deliver intense vibrations exactly where it feels the best. If you know vibrating toys are something you love, or if you're looking to try one out, we'd recommend the B-Vibe Rimming Plug 2, or the Backdoor Banger. Both are on the pricier end, but the vibrations they provide really are something else! If you're on a tighter budget, the Mighty Mini offers similar vibrations at a much lower price.

There's no better way to guarantee an explosive ending than by using a butt plug that can deliver intense vibrations exactly where it feels the best.

Vibrations can be a double-edged sword, though, due to their intense stimulation. Some people find this to be far too much stimulation, and if that's you, don't sweat it - there are a lot of people who agree with you! If you're looking for a quality plug without vibrating features, we'd recommend the Mood Naughty plug, or if you're feeling adventurous, the Titanmen Master Tool No. 4, which offer an intensely pleasurable stretch!

Keep storage in mind

No matter which butt plug you choose, you're going to have to store it somewhere. However, depending on the discreetness of the design, some people aren't comfortable with simply putting their plug away in a drawer or anywhere else for that matter.

If discreetness is something that's important to you, it might be a good idea to purchase a plug with a storage bag. Both of B-Vibe's plugs on this list - the Vibrating & Weighted Snug Plug, and the Rimming Plug 2 - come with a bag for storage, meaning they're much more inconspicuous wherever you put them.

Evaluate your budget

Setting a budget - and sticking to it - is the best thing to do if you're in the market for a new sex toy. You don't want to impulse-buy a fancy and expensive toy only to find you aren't sure about how it feels to use it!

It can be helpful to base your budget on your experience level. If you're a beginner, you may be unsure of your preferences, so it's best to find a less costly toy to try out so you aren't wasting money on something you end up not being into. The mood naughty is a simple plug that's nice and cheap, but if you're looking to explore other features, the Mighty Mini is a great budget vibrating plug.

Consider advanced features

Vibrations are a very common sex toy feature, but there are far more advanced features that offer wildly varied sensations, that are great fun for experienced users to explore!

One of these features is rotations. Several plugs on this list feature rotating rows of beads in the stem of the plug - this provides a gorgeous rim-job feeling, alongside the prostate stimulation that you'd expect from a good plug. The Anal Aventures Platinum is a fantastic rotating plug, which vibrates for even more pleasure!

One of these features is rotations. Several plugs on this list feature rotating rows of beads in the stem of the plug

Weight is another advanced feature. Weighted plugs increase the pressure and feeling of fullness to an incredibly satisfying degree. The B-Vibe Vibrating & Weighted Snug Plug is the perfect weight for those looking for added pressure, and Icicles No. 47 is similarly weighted but is glass instead of silicone for a different feeling.

The Anal Fantasy Elite combines two further advanced features, being a gaper with a hollow tunnel. Gapers provide intense stretching, and the hollow tunnel allows more sex toys (or any other body-safe items) to be inserted for maximum stimulation!

Decide on size

When it comes to butt plugs, size does indeed matter! Anything too small and you might not get the stimulation you want, and anything too big might end up being painful - in a bad way.

Newcomers to butt stuff should always start with something smaller, or opt for an anal training kit if possible. As luck would have it, the Colt Silicone Anal Trainer butt plug kit is available on our site, and we reckon it's the best of the bunch!

If you're more experienced, you're probably used to smaller plugs, so you might be looking for something a little bigger. Most of the plugs on this list are fairly intermediately-sized, but if you're in the market for something that's a real challenge, we'd recommend the Titanmen Master Tool No. 4 - it's sure to test your limits!

Summary

Butt plugs are simply amazing - there are no two ways about it! They're such a versatile sex toy, being incredible for solo sex and a great way to spice up sex with a partner. As you've seen from this list, they also come in many varieties - silicone, glass vibrating, rotating... there's really something for everyone!

Since this is the best list, every plug we've discussed is a top-notch toy, and certainly a worthy addition to any butt plug collection

If you are looking for that one perfect plug though, remember to set and stick to a budget, and think about your material and feature preferences, as well as your level of experience. Through careful consideration of this list, you're bound to find the butt plug for you.

Side Note

This best of list will be periodically updated as better products become available or products simply no longer perform as well. As with all best of lists, this will be a living document.

We take our recommendations very seriously

We have worked intensively on developing a product evaluation system that takes in consideration the following factors:

  • Materials
  • Electronic Components
  • Safety Testing Data
  • US Regulatory Information
  • 510(k) Certifications
  • Our Experts Evaluation

Learn more about our selection process

Search