10 Best Butt Plugs for Men in 2024

Butt plugs are among the most popular sex toys around. Take a look at any good sex toy retailer and you'll be met with a huge array of plugs to meet such intense demand!

Their popularity is well earned; they're reliable, being a tried and tested way of achieving anal pleasure and prostate orgasms, and they come in so many different varieties - so many in fact that choosing which plug is the best for you can be difficult.

Regardless of whether you're a beginner who's looking to obtain your very first plug or a seasoned butt plug pro hoping to add something amazing to your collection, we're here for you. We've put together this handy list containing the plugs that we consider to be the best choices for men looking to expand their arsenal, updated for 2024.

After taking a look at each plug, we'll go over some of the things you need to think about to narrow down your choice, including material, features, and size.

How We Put Together This Guide

We used the following criteria to put together this guide to the best butt plugs:

• Material quality
• Durability
• Level of restriction
• Level of comfort
• Ease of use

Best Butt Plugs of 2024: Our Recommendations

B-Vibe Rimming Plug 2 | Rotating and Vibrating Butt Plug

For 2024, our pick for the best overall butt plug on our site is the same as last year's pick - the B-Vibe Rimming Plug 2. Its range of features, including both rotations and vibrations (which aim to replicate the sensations experienced during a rimjob) are still impressive and make this plug stand out from the crowd.

There are 7 unique modes to play with here, each of which features different speeds and intensities of the vibrations and rotations. Cycling through these modes is super easy with the included wireless remote control, which speeds up finding the right settings for your current mood.

The body of the plug is built from premium, seamless medical-grade silicone which is nice and comfortable, and thanks to the flared base, it stays perfectly in place. All the vibrations come courtesy of a discreet motor in the tip of the plug. Though they're quiet, don't let that fool you - they get very powerful at the higher settings.

Found in the stem of the plug are several rows of spinning beads - these provide the rotating sensation (for rimjob stimulation) which we found makes it a lot easier to achieve an orgasm when combined with the vibrations. At the bottom of the plug, you'll find the flared base which helps keep it safe and works well as a stand.

With the included USB charger, it's easy to keep the plug charged and ready to go. It also comes with a discreet carrying case, and an anal play guide. The Rimming Plug 2 is easy to use, powerfully pleasurable, and features just the right number of modes to ensure there's something for everyone. That's why it won multiple awards, and why it's the overall best on our site.

Results From Our Testers

• Rotating beads aren't very realistic, but they feel great
• Vibrations feel great too
• Lots of settings to have fun with
• Remote is good for hands-free use
• Feels nice and premium

Pros and Cons

Mood Naughty Black Silicone Butt Plug by Doc Johnson

If you're new to butt plugs and would like to find something suitable for your needs in 2024, we'd recommend this Mood Naughty plug by Doc Johnson. It's our best plug for beginners this year thanks to its classic flared design and range of sizes that mean you can choose how you want to start.

This is a very basic plug that lacks any additional features, but this is part of why it's a good butt plug for beginners - it doesn't offer any challenges that might be overstimulating. It's just a simple, classic plug made from soft silicone, with a tapered tip that makes it easy to insert regardless of which size you go for.

If you have experience with some anal play and are a bit more adventurous you could go for a size up - it's up to you really. The range of sizes means that these plugs make good basic additions for anyone.

The base of the plug is flared and doubles as a handle, which helps make it extra safe. Safety is vital with butt plugs as you don't want to get anything stuck, or worse, lost. The flared handle gives you something to grab onto once you're done, and the smooth silicone means it's easy to remove.

It's a comfortable enough plug to wear for extended periods of time, and it's also waterproof meaning you can take it with you in the bath or shower. This also means it's nice and easy to clean, and works well with water-based lube - we wouldn't recommend using any other varieties of lube with this plug.

Results From Our Testers

• Nice and simple plug that does exactly what you expect
• Silicone is smooth
• They're easy to insert thanks to the taper
• Range of sizes makes them suitable for beginners and experts
• They're probably too basic for advanced users

Pros and Cons

B-Vibe Vibrating & Weighted Snug Plug Black XL

The B-Vibe vibrating weighted snug plug is perfect for anyone looking to upgrade their current plug to something more luxurious - we consider it the best premium butt plug available for 2024. When compared to a basic plug, it's a great upgrade in terms of how good it feels inside you, as well as its advanced features.

This medical-grade silicone butt plug feels very nice even without utilizing any of the vibrating features due to its premium materials, and its weighted nature. The torpedo-style shape also allows for easy insertion, meaning you shouldn't have too much difficulty getting it inside nice and comfortably.

You definitely do want to try out the vibrations though. In total there are 4 vibration settings and 6 unique patterns. This range gives you a lot to play around with, and working up from the lower settings is a great way to avoid overstimulation.

The best way to use this plug is with a ton of water-based lube for a pleasurably slick experience. Once fully charged with the included USB cable, it should last a good while. With the flexible neck which ends in a handle, the plug remains safe through extensive use.

The price tag is pretty high, but we feel this plug makes up for that with the comfort that comes from the combination of its shape, XL size, weight, seamless silicone design, and included travel bag. Combine all that with the various settings of vibrations, and it's easy to see why the B-Vibe Vibrating & Weighted snug plug has this place on the list.

Results From Our Testers

• The weightiness of this plug feels super nice when it's inserted
• Good range of vibrations will suit lots of people
• Torpedo shape and bendable neck help with insertion
• It's big which is good for those with experience but not for those without
• It's a bit awkward to change settings due to the placement of the buttons

Pros and Cons

Nu Sensuelle Power Plug 20 Function Remote Control Vibrating Butt Plug

The plug we consider to be the best vibrating butt plug available on our site in 2024 is the Nu Sensuelle Power Plug. It's nice and slim and there are loads of vibrating modes to choose from that range from gentle and tickling to super powerful - it also comes with a convenient wireless remote.

Overall there are 20 different vibration modes on offer here, which gives you a hell of a lot to play around with, and gives you lots of room to work your way up from the gentler settings, which is what we recommend. It also means this is a decent plug no matter your experience.

You might want something a little larger if you're experienced, but there's no doubt this plug feels good regardless. It's built from smooth silicone which also helps with insertion, and it's also waterproof, despite the intense vibrations, so you can take it in the bath. The wireless remote makes flicking through settings easy, and also means you can pass it to a partner to let them control your fun, which is always a good time. This is another premium butt plug, but the vibrations, as well as basically everything else, are fantastic.

Results From Our Testers

• Lots of vibrations to mess around with
• Good range from gentle to powerful
• Compact shape is great for beginners and intermediate users
• Might be too thin for experts but the vibrations will help
• Great for couples play

Pros and Cons

Colt Anal Trainer Kit | Set of 3 Black Butt Plugs

Our best rubber butt plug for 2024 isn't a single butt plug; it's actually a set of three. This anal trainer kit from Colt contains three different sizes of butt plug, allowing you to work from the smallest plug up to bigger and better things, all with a single purchase. Each of these plugs is made from high-quality, body-safe PVC. The plugs are a good medium between being hard and soft, which helps with anal penetration.

The plugs range from 4 to 6 inches in length, and 1 to 1.5 inches in width. This means that even the largest plug isn't super oversized or anything - just the right size to be achievable for anyone with a little practice. Experts may want something a little bigger though.

The designs of the plugs are all essentially the same, with the only real difference being the size. This means you can expect the same smoothness, quality of materials, and ease of insertion with each plug. They all have flared bases for safety as well.

As this is a kit containing multiple anal sex toys, it is more expensive than buying a single basic plug. However, most people who are into butt plugs enjoy the process of increasing in size as time goes on, and this kit is a nice and simple way to plan to do that.

Results From Our Testers

• Basic but high-quality set of butt plugs
• It's great to be able to work up from a smaller size
• Quite cheap for 3 plugs
• PVC isn't quite as soft as silicone
• They're all fairly easy to insert

Pros and Cons

Anal Fantasy Elite Fantasy Mega Anal Gaper Clear Glass Open Tunnel Butt Plug

The Mega Anal Gaper from Pipedream's Anal Fantasy Elite Collection is this year's pick for the best glass butt plug available on our site. If you're looking for a glass plug in 2024, we'd recommend this plug due to its premium, smooth material and its open tunnel design.

This butt plug is made entirely out of Pyrex glass which has a very smooth finish that makes it feel great to insert. The glass also means it's compatible with both water-based and silicone-based lube. Water-based works fine but silicone-based lube makes the toy even smoother and much easier to insert.

The glass material also means this butt plug is great for temperature play. Glass holds on to heat much better than other materials, and simply by submerging it in hot or cold water for a few minutes will be enough to heat it up or cool it down for a good while. This helps get more longevity out of the plug.

You've probably also noticed that this butt plug has a hollow opening going all the way through. This hole lets you insert objects such as sex toys, your fingers, or even body-safe liquids while the plug is inside you. All of this opens up a lot of potential for extra stimulation, so it's a feature we enjoyed.

It's worth mentioning that this is a pretty big plug - it's called a gaper after all. It has a length of 5 inches which isn't huge, but the width of 2 inches will give you a good stretch. We'd recommend this plug to anyone with a bit of experience with butt plugs.

Results From Our Testers

• Glass material is weighty and smooth
• Works very well with silicone lube
• Hollow tube is a neat addition
• Tapered tip helps with insertion
• Probably too big for beginners

Pros and Cons

Kiiroo Ohmibod Lumen Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating Butt Plug

The Kiiroo OhMiBod Lumen is what we reckon to be the best silicone butt plug we offer on our site in 2024. It's packed with features, vibration modes, as well as patented Velvet Wave comfort technology (more on that later) that make it feel great to use both with its advanced capabilities and without.

This plug is made from soft silicone that features the Velvet Wave comfort technology we just mentioned. What Kiiroo means by this is that the silicone is built with multiple cushioned ridges to add to the overall comfort of using the plug while also increasing stimulation - it works well in our experience.

When used in manual mode, there are 4 vibration and pulsation settings. These four settings do feel good, but don't offer much variety or fine-tuning; that's where the other modes come in.

The Lumen can connect to two different apps via Bluetooth - the OhMiBod Remote App, and the Kiiroo FeelConnect App. The former is just a wireless way of controlling the vibrations, but the latter lets you sync up to other sex toys, and can be used with long-distance partners.

Club Vibe mode lets the plug sync up to ambient sounds - this works with anything really, from a speaker playing music in your room, audio from adult content, or even your partner speaking. Results vary based on the volume and other ambient sounds in your area, but this is an interesting feature.

Overall this is a high-quality silicone plug with enough features to keep you busy for a while. The manual mode vibrations could have more variation, but this is made up for by the interactive capabilities, and Club Vibe feature. If you were wondering why it's called the Lumen, that's because there's a glowing blue light on the base.

Results From Our Testers

• Silicone feels great with the Velvet Wave cushioned ridges
• Vibrations feel good but there are not many manual settings
• Interactive capabilities are great for long-distance
• Club Vibe mode is unique and works well a lot of the time
• Battery life could be longer, it's less than half of the charge time

Pros and Cons

Anal Adventured Platinum 5.75-inch Drive Rechargeable Silicone Butt Plug with Remote by Blush Novelties

Here we have another vibrating and rotating butt plug, but this time they're on our best rotating plug for 2024 - the Anal Adventures Platinum. It features multiple rows of pleasure beads that provide rimjob-style stimulation which feels great.

The 10 vibrating and gyrating functions along with the rotating beads are controlled with the included wireless remote for hands-free use, which is also facilitated by the unique anchor base. It's also super easy to insert the plug thanks to its smooth, penis head tip.

Built out of platinum-cured Puria silicone - which mainly means it's cleaner and more durable than regular silicone - this plug is very soft, and gently warms to your body temperature for an extremely comfortable experience.

The easy-to-insert penis tip and wide range of vibration and rotation settings mean that this butt plug is a great buy for anyone regardless of their level of experience - both beginners and veterans will be able to get something good out of this one.

The Anal Adventures Platinum butt plug is full of features, simple to use thanks to the remote control, and also dirt-proof which makes remaining hygienic a piece of cake. All of these add up, making it a very good choice for anyone.

Results From Our Testers

• Rotations feel particularly good
• Great range of vibrations and gyrations which feel great
• Easy to insert thanks to soft silicone and tapered tip
• Wireless remote is convenient
• It's nice and compact but might be too small for some

Pros and Cons

Anal Fantasy Elite Small Anal Gaper Clear Glass Open Tunnel Butt Plug by Pipedream Products

Another of Pipedream's Anal Fantasy Elite butt plugs has found its way onto our list, this time as our best hollow tunnel butt plug for 2024. This is a smaller version of our best glass plug entry, meaning its high-quality materials and hollow tunnel can be experienced by a wider range of users.

This visual element is uncommon with butt plugs, but it helps out a lot especially when you consider the hollow tunnel. Built into the toy is an opening that goes all the way through. It's just the right shape to allow for the insertion of other anal toys and body-safe objects and liquids. You could even use your (or a partner's) finger for some more targeted stimulation.

The borosilicate glass material means that this plug is compatible with water and silicone lube, the latter of which pairs perfectly with the toy, providing a lot of extra slickness and cushioning. This, along with the tapered tip, makes the toy very easy to use, even if you're new to gapers.

This plug is nice and easy to clean with soapy water, and due to the flared base, you don't need to be worried about it getting sucked too far in. As we mentioned earlier, if you're looking to get into gapers, this is a good toy to start off with, and the hollow tube adds lots of extra options.

Results From Our Testers

• The glass feels nice and smooth to insert and once inside
• Silicone lube works perfectly here
• The hollow tube adds an extra layer of usability
• It's not too big but still gives a good stretch
• Experts may want something that gives a larger gape

Pros and Cons

Smooth Anal Dilator Expansion Plug Kit Black

If you're in the market for a butt plug kit in 2024, the kit we'd recommend is this smooth anal dilator expansion plug kit. It contains 5 plugs of graduated sizes that allow you to start as small as you need before working your way up to larger, more filling, and more stimulating plugs with relative ease.

Each of these plugs is made out of TPE rubber which is soft yet firm, and useful for stretching. The smallest plug is 3.4 inches long and 1 inch wide, and the largest is 5 inches long and 1.9 inches wide. The other plugs fall somewhere between, meaning you won't be overstretched as you progress.

They all have flared bases too, which helps them not get stuck inside you. They're only compatible with water-based lube though, so be sure to use enough of it. All of these plugs are fully waterproof, so you can take them all in the bath or shower if you feel like it. They're all quite comfortable too, meaning they're great for wearing during sex. Aside from the size differences, all the designs are the exact same, so you know what you're getting with each one.

As with other anal trainer kits, they are more expensive than buying a single plug. However, for 5 basic plugs, we think the price is pretty fair, especially if you're a beginner who intends to start with the smallest plug. Overall, they're very simple, but they do a good job of training you towards experiencing the wider world of butt plugs.

Results From Our Testers

• They increase in size very gradually which means they work great for training
• The TPE material is firm but soft enough to be comfortable
• The tapered tips make them easy to insert and more pleasurable
• They're very smooth which feels nice
• The material isn't quite as soft as silicone

Pros and Cons

Become a Sex Toy Reviewer: Your Path to Free Sex Toys

Join Our Tester Program

How to choose a butt plug

So - those are the butt plugs that we believe to be the best on our site, with each one being a standout in its individual category. I'm sure a few have caught your eye, but that only complicates things if you're looking to find your perfect plug!

To that end, here we'll go over a few of the things you need to keep in mind in order to narrow down your choice out of all these incredible plugs, to land on one that you can be confident will be the best for your needs!

Know the materials

1. Know the materials

All the plugs on this list are made from one of two materials: silicone or glass. Whichever of these materials a plug is built from can greatly affect a number of things, such as how it feels, how it reacts to temperature, and what kinds of lube it can be safely used with.

Silicone toys are often super soft and velvety, feeling incredible to touch and insert. These toys will usually remain at a fairly consistent temperature. Most silicone toys are only compatible with water-based lube - it's important to always check the labels and instructions of any toy or lube you purchase to find out any compatibility issues.

Glass toys are very firm, which makes them easy to insert (especially with lube) and gives a much different feeling as your muscles squeeze around the plug. Glass plugs can be quite cold, but are easily heated and will warm up to body temperature as you use them. If you're into the slipperiness and cushioning of silicone lube, you're in luck here as most glass toys can be used with it.

2. Consider vibrating features

There's no better way to guarantee an explosive ending than by using a butt plug that can deliver intense vibrations exactly where it feels the best. Vibrations can be a double-edged sword, though, due to their intense stimulation.

This one is simple - if you know you're into vibrations, a vibrating toy will do you good. If you're not, go for a manual toy, or a toy with another kind of stimulation that you know works for you, such as a rotating neck.

3. Keep storage in mind

No matter which butt plug you choose, you're going to have to store it somewhere. However, depending on the discreetness of the design, some people aren't comfortable with simply putting their plug away in a drawer or anywhere else for that matter. In these situations, you might want to purchase a plug with a design that isn't too phallic, or one that comes with a badge or storage case.

4. Evaluate your budget

Setting a budget - and sticking to it - is the best thing to do if you're in the market for a new sex toy. You don't want to impulse-buy a fancy and expensive toy only to find you aren't sure about how it feels to use it!

It can be helpful to base your budget on your experience level. If you're a beginner, you may be unsure of your preferences, so it's best to find a less costly toy to try out so you aren't wasting money on something you end up not being into.

RECOMMENDED READING

Best Budget Male Sex Toys of 2024

5. Consider advanced features

Vibrations are a very common sex toy feature, but there are far more advanced features that offer wildly varied sensations, that are great fun for experienced users to explore!

One of these features is rotations. Several plugs on this list feature rotating rows of beads in the stem of the plug to replicate a rimjob feeling, alongside the prostate stimulation that you'd expect from a good plug.

Weight is another advanced feature. Weighted plugs increase the pressure and feeling of fullness to an incredibly satisfying degree.

Gapers provide intense stretching, and the hollow tunnel allows more sex toys (or any other body-safe items) to be inserted for maximum stimulation!

6. Decide on size

When it comes to butt plugs, size does indeed matter! Anything too small and you might not get the stimulation you want, and anything too big might end up being painful - in a bad way.

Newcomers to butt stuff should always start with something smaller, or opt for an anal training kit if possible. If you're more experienced, you're probably used to smaller plugs, so you might be looking for something a little bigger. Most of the plugs on this list are fairly intermediately-sized and work well for everyone.

Summary

Butt plugs are simply amazing - there are no two ways about it! They're such a versatile sex toy, being incredible for solo sex and a great way to spice up sex with a partner. As you've seen from this list, they also come in many varieties - silicone, glass vibrating, rotating... there's something for everyone.

If you are looking for that one perfect plug though, remember to set and stick to a budget, and think about your material and feature preferences, as well as your level of experience. Through careful consideration of this list, you're bound to find the butt plug for you.